I wanted a challenge, I chose piping. And crème pâtissière, but more of that later. I haven’t ‘done’ piping before. I feel the majority of baking enthusiasts have a broader experience in this field because of this god awful obsession with American style cupcakes. To be perfectly honest, I rather dislike them. I am aware this is a huge generalisation BUT they’re overly sweet, the icing to sponge ratio is way out and frankly, I don’t want to eat something that looks like its topping has been formed from what comes out the arse of a My Little Pony.
Because of my distaste for the sickly, pretty swirls of coloured sugar I don’t tend to bake them but if I do, I certainly don’t bedeck them with swirls of piped icing. My loathing is only my own enemy because now I am ignorant in the world of piping.
To rectify this situation I came upon a baked good that would challenge me in a variety of ways: Éclairs.
Éclairs are made from choux pastry, something which in itself I have never found difficult to make, however offering your little buns to the AGA gods is a different matter. I searched all over the internet for people’s experiences with AGAs and choux pastry and the only thing I found was one woman bemoaning her AGA for destroying every attempt. Great.
And so to Mary.... I checked her AGA book and yes there were instructions for baking éclairs so I felt safe. The actual recipe I wanted to use however was one of Raymond Blanc’s. Raymond’s choux pastry and crème pâtissière recipe {http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/chocolate_clairs_03600}, James Martin’s icing recipe {http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/recipes/classic_chocolate_clair_72793} and Mary Berry’s cooking instructions. What was there to go wrong?
The actual piping was not too bad. I think my choux pastry was slightly too runny to achieve a perfect form but we live and learn. The runniness did make getting the pastry into the bag and keeping it there long enough to ready myself to pipe a bit of a messy mission; choux pastry may have ended up getting in many other places than the tray but a sufficient amount made it on there in some semblance of an éclair shape.
| When things were still clean |
![]() |
| Not too appalling |
![]() |
| Check out that difference! |
Perhaps I should have turned the tray around mid-bake, but then that could have caused them to not fulfill their puff potential. Mary’s lucky I had the good sense to check on them 5 minutes before she told me to anyway because in another 5 minutes those little guys could have been sad charred stumps laid out on my tray.
Judging the first tray on their looks (it’s a cruel, superficial world), I put the next batch slightly lower and kept my eye on them (rather difficult through a cast iron door) and they came out much happier.Tentatively following Mary’s instructions to the next step, all éclairs got slashed and put in the Simmering Oven to dry out, no further harm came to them.
I must admit, on seeing the mixed bag of success of the first batch of éclairs, the old Beth would probably have had a mini meltdown. A painful memory is flashing before my eyes in which a failed attempt to melt white chocolate caused me to burst into tears. It was late at night, I was tired, my class at school were expecting delightful treats the following day; it all was a bit too much. But I am not (usually) that sensitive anymore. I would soldier on with these éclairs, even if the next thing to be made was something I’d never made before.
Crème pâtissière: a pastry cream. And you know what, it’s surprisingly easy to make. Just make sure you let the heated milk cool slightly before you add it to the egg yolk, sugar, flour, cornflour mix unless you’re going for the scrambled egg custard variety.
Heat the vanilla milk, slowly add it to the rest of the mixed ingredients, whisking constantly. Return it to the pan, bring it up to the boil, again with the whisking, then let it simmer for another 2 minutes or so until it has thickened. And then you’re done.
Unless you want to make it better and flavour it with chocolate, which I did.
Apparently pastry cream disgustingly forms a skin if you leave it out in the open, so mine got a layer of cling film patted upon it and left to cool.
| Not actually scary to make |
Heads up; because I made the crème pâtissière correctly it was much more fun to pipe than the choux pastry. So, do things right first time and it’s swell.
And if anyone has any doubts, pastry cream is ridiculously delicious, I for one am never filling an éclair or profiterole with cream ever again.![]() |
| Much more fun to pipe |
I really did do everything right for James’ fondant chocolate topping. But it just didn’t taste good (Note: always try the icing before it goes anywhere near the rest of your food). So I wasn’t going to encase my éclairs in a sorry excuse for a chocolate icing after I’d piped twice to achieve them.
So a second icing was made thanks to the BBC GoodFood website and it was a delight, thank god.
![]() |
| They do look quite impressive |
And no, I did not pipe it on.
| Even the dud ones look good. Icing; a poor bake's best friend. |








